LED vs. fluorescent: what is sourced and what you must measure
| Feature | Modern LED panels | T5 fluorescent tubes |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Moderate to high | Low |
| Running cost | Measured watts x hours x your tariff | Measured watts x hours x your tariff |
| Heat at the canopy | Low; the heatsink and driver carry the rest | Cool enough to run 2-4 in above seedlings (Illinois) |
| Replacement | ENERGY STAR indoor minimum: 25,000 hours to L70 | Tubes are replaced when they fail or fade |
| Distance above seedlings | Extension guides give 4-6 in for lights in general; check the panel's PPFD | 2-4 inches (Illinois); about 5 inches (UMass) |
| Spectrum | White full-spectrum is a sound default | Cool white or warm white |
If you have decided to move your herb garden indoors, you have already accepted that the sun cannot do all the work. As we outlined in How Much Light Do Indoor Herbs Actually Need?, culinary herbs need a lot of light to grow well.
When you start shopping for artificial lights, you hit a fork in the road. Half the internet recommends T5 fluorescent tubes, and the other half swears by full-spectrum LEDs.
Quick answer: are LED or fluorescent grow lights better for herbs?
For most home growers, LED is the better choice. ENERGY STAR’s minimum for an indoor LED luminaire is 25,000 hours to L70, so check that a panel publishes an L70 rating. An LED has no tubes to replace and sheds its heat through the heatsink rather than at the leaves. Fluorescent tubes win mainly on price, and they still start seedlings well. If budget decides it, a T5 fixture is a sound start. Otherwise buy an LED.
How T5 fluorescent grow lights work
High-output fluorescent tubes, the T5 size (5/8 of an inch in diameter), were the standard for indoor seed starting before white LEDs got affordable. A phosphor coating inside the tube glows when current passes through it.
What fluorescents do well
- Cheap upfront cost. A dual-tube shop light costs a fraction of a premium LED panel, which makes the barrier to entry low.
- Soft, even light. A long tube spreads light along its length, so there are no hot spots under the fixture.
- Good for seedlings. Illinois Extension and UMass both describe seedlings under fluorescent tubes kept very close. Illinois gives 2 to 4 inches above the plants, and UMass says as close as possible, about 5 inches, lifting the lights as plants grow. UMass also grows them under fluorescent lights for 12 to 16 hours per day. Iowa State says most seeds germinate at a soil temperature of 68 to 86 °F, so check the shelf’s temperature too.
Where fluorescents fall short
- Heat. Every watt a fixture draws ends up as heat in the room whatever the technology, so a closet warms with measured watts, not with the tube or the diode. That matters for cool-season herbs like cilantro. Heat also changes how much light a herb wants; see grow light heat management.
- Replacement. Tubes are consumables, and they are glass.
- Bulk. A tube fixture takes more overhead room than a flat panel.
How LED grow lights work
An LED passes current through a semiconductor chip that emits light. Early horticultural LEDs were red and blue only, which gave the purple “blurple” glow. White-LED panels now cover the whole band plants use, so the shelf looks like a normal lit kitchen.
What LEDs do well
- Long rated life. ENERGY STAR’s luminaire requirements set L70(6k) of at least 25,000 hours for indoor luminaires. L70 is the time until output falls to 70 percent of new. On a 12 to 16 hour day, 25,000 hours is roughly four to six years.
- Less heat at the leaf. The energy that does not become light still becomes heat. In an LED it leaves through the heatsink and driver, so the fixture needs air around it even though the canopy stays cooler.
- Easy to pair with a white spectrum. White full-spectrum is a sound default, because evidence for exotic red to blue ratios in home leafy-herb growing is thin. See grow light spectrum explained.
Where LEDs fall short
- Price. Good panels cost more up front, and the heatsink is part of why.
- Intensity. A strong panel hung too close can bleach a shade-tolerant herb such as mint. Raise it or dim it, and use the PPFD method in grow light distance for seedlings to set the height; how to tell if a grow light is burning plants shows what to look for.
What does each one cost to run?
Neither technology has a price you can look up, because the bill depends on your fixture’s real draw, your hours and your tariff. Take the measured watts from a plug-in meter, multiply by hours per day and days per month, divide by 1,000 and multiply by your rate. The worked method is in grow light electricity cost. A greenhouse comparison uses the same arithmetic, plus replacement lamps and cooling.
Two cautions apply to any comparison you read. “Equivalent wattage” claims are marketing, because watts measure power drawn, not light delivered. A fixture’s wattage on the box is a starting point, not a result; the wattage guide explains why.
How to compare two fixtures on the light plants get
Purdue Extension defines photosynthetically active radiation as light between 400 and 700 nm, and measures it as PPFD in micromoles per square metre per second. Lux and foot-candles are based on what the human eye sees, mostly green, so Purdue calls them not appropriate for indicating plant photosynthesis. Purdue’s conversion from foot-candles to PAR is 0.20 for sunlight and 0.13 for HPS lamps, a 35 percent difference on the same meter reading. A lux meter therefore cannot rank a tube against an LED.
The one rule of thumb that exists, about 15 micromoles per square metre per second for every 1,000 lux, was derived for white LEDs only and is a bioRxiv preprint, not peer-reviewed. It does not hold for fluorescent tubes or blurple fixtures. For the full picture see lux vs. PPFD.
What matters is the daily total. Purdue gives DLI as PPFD × hours of light × 0.0036 (the often-quoted 0.0864 is the same factor for a full 24 hours), so 200 µmol/m²/s on a 14-hour timer is about 10 mol per square metre per day. MSU Extension lists 12 mol per square metre per day or more for leafy greens and herbs in controlled environments, with lettuce at 12 to 14 at minimum. Put your fixture’s measured PPFD and hours into the DLI calculator and judge both fixtures against that target.
Can plants grow under artificial light, and which bulbs count?
Yes. Plants use the 400-700 nm band regardless of its source, and a fixture that delivers enough PPFD for enough hours will grow herbs. That is why a standard fluorescent office tube or an ordinary LED bulb can keep a plant alive when held close; they only fall short when too little light arrives at the leaf. For the bulb question see can regular LED bulbs grow plants.
Which one for a small space or hydroponics?
The hydroponic question is the same as the soil one. Roots in water do not change what the leaf needs, so choose on PPFD at the canopy, hours and heat in the enclosure. In a closet or cabinet the heat leaving the fixture decides it. An LED keeps heat off the canopy but not out of the room, so leave a path for air. UMass warns that seedlings stretch when it is too warm, not only when the light is weak. For fixture count and coverage, see grow light coverage.
The verdict: which should you buy?
If you want product-level advice, go to Best Grow Lights for Herbs (Buyer’s Guide). If you are only choosing a technology, buy an LED: long rated life, no tubes, less heat at the leaves. If you have a tight budget and are starting seeds, a T5 is a reasonable start. If you are buying a panel, you can browse full-spectrum LED grow light panels on Amazon (Amazon, opens in a new tab) and check the listed PPFD and wattage before you choose.
Related Guides
Sources
- ENERGY STAR Program Requirements for Luminaires (L70, LM-80, TM-21)
- Purdue Extension HO-238-W, Measuring Daily Light Integral in a Greenhouse
- MSU Extension, Lighting Greenhouse Vegetables
- Illinois Extension, What’s wrong with my seedlings?
- UMass Amherst CAFE, Starting Seeds Indoors
- Iowa State Extension, How to Successfully Start Seed Indoors
- University of Minnesota Extension, Lighting for indoor plants and starting seeds
- Sharakshane (2018), bioRxiv preprint
Still deciding on your setup?
Once you choose between LED and fluorescent, read these guides to figure out how many hours to run them and how high to hang them.
Common questions
Are LED or fluorescent grow lights better for herbs?
LED suits most home herb growers: ENERGY STAR sets a minimum of 25,000 hours to L70 for indoor LED luminaires, there are no tubes to replace, and a fixture with a heatsink keeps heat away from the leaves. A fluorescent T5 fixture costs less to buy and still starts seedlings well. Compare the specific fixtures on measured watts and measured PPFD at the canopy.
Can I just use a standard fluorescent office light?
It will grow something, but it is a poor tool for herbs. Purdue Extension notes that lux and foot-candles measure light as the human eye sees it, mostly green, so they say little about what a plant uses. A tube sold as a plant light and a tube sold for offices cannot be told apart by a lux reading. Measure PPFD or keep the tubes close, 2 to 4 inches above seedlings per Illinois Extension.
Why are "blurple" (blue/purple) LED lights so common?
Red and blue diodes were an early way to cover the wavelengths plants absorb. White full-spectrum LEDs cover the whole 400-700 nm band and are easier on the eye. The evidence for specific red-to-blue ratios in home herb growing is thin, so a white LED is a reasonable default.
Do LED lights ever burn out?
Usually they fade slowly instead of failing outright. ENERGY STAR defines L70 as the time until output falls to 70 percent of new. Our guide to how long LED grow lights actually last covers the design-goal hours and how to tell when a fixture has faded.